Tier List

Starfall Star Pets Tier List

S–C rankings for farming, luck hunting, and event loadouts in Starfall on Roblox.

Last updated:

Pets Tier List

This pets tier list ranks Starfall companions by how hard they push Stardust income and luck while you catch stars. It is meant for live Roblox accounts on the Darkcrest Games simulator, including players who just redeemed PETUPDATE for the Epic Harbor Otter.

Read Star Pets for hatching rules, and keep Codes claimed so free Epics count toward your roster.

Tier overview

S tier — equip whenever possible

  • Best-in-slot luck pets from your highest island egg — maximize rare and bonus star rates during meteor showers.
  • Top Stardust multipliers from the same pool — best for lantern funding and island unlock banking.
  • Event-limited Epics that beat both stats — keep even after the event if numbers remain elite.

S-tier pets are why you save Card Draws for your best island instead of dumping them on starter eggs.

A tier — excellent defaults

  • Epic Harbor Otter (code) — outstanding early and still fine into mid-game until a hatched pet wins both multipliers.
  • Strong island Epics with slightly uneven stats — great when you need either luck or dust but not both at peak.
  • Flexible rares that fit dual loadouts — easy swaps between farm and STARFALL event presets.

B tier — situational

  • Mid rares that only shine on a specific island
  • Pets with cosmetic prestige but middling multipliers
  • Older Epics outpaced by a newer egg pool after an update

C tier — replace soon

  • Common starter pets with negligible multipliers
  • Duplicates kept only for collection flex
  • Anything unequipped for more than two island tiers

Loadout templates

Farming loadout: highest Stardust pet + solid lantern duration (lanterns tier list).

Meteor loadout: highest luck pet + group +10% luck + cleared inventory for Golden/Rainbow/Huge finds (Stars hub).

Boss night loadout: balanced pet before Sky Beasts so post-fight upgrades are affordable.

Harbor Otter placement notes

Redeem PETUPDATE on day one via How to Redeem. The Otter belongs in A tier for most new accounts and can flirt with S-tier value during the first lantern breakpoint because it costs zero Stardust. Demote it only when a hatched pet proves better in a side-by-side compare on the same island.

Spending Card Draws with the list

  1. Check which island is your best (Floating Islands).
  2. Open eggs from that pool.
  3. Equip anything that enters A or S for your goal.
  4. Keep one B-tier specialty only if it uniquely helps secret star routes.
  5. Retire C-tier from the active bar.

Common ranking mistakes

  • Judging pets by look alone
  • Opening all draws before unlocking the next island egg
  • Refusing to replace a sentimental starter pet
  • Running a luck pet while your lantern still fails basic traces — fix light first with Lanterns & Stardust

Side-by-side compare method

When two pets look close on paper, equip each for a ten-minute farm on the same island with the same lantern. Record Stardust gained, rare sparks noticed, and how often you felt starved for luck during near-miss traces. The pet that wins your real route belongs in the active slot even if community chatter disagrees.

Re-run the compare after every egg opening session from Star Pets and after island unlocks in Floating Islands. Keep a farming preset and a meteor preset so you are not improvising when a STARFALL shower starts. Cross-check lantern synergy on the lanterns tier list and bank currency advice from Lanterns & Stardust.

If scripts auto-equip the wrong companion, disable that toggle using notes on Scripts and manually lock your S or A choices before Sky Beasts. Rankings only help when the pet you trust is actually equipped.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers for Starfall players.

Where does the Harbor Otter rank?

A tier for most early accounts, and effectively S-tier value because it comes free from the PETUPDATE code.

Should I run luck or Stardust pets?

Stardust pets for lantern funding; luck pets during meteor showers and rare hunts.

When do rankings change?

When new islands or egg pools arrive — recheck after updates.

Do common pets ever stay relevant?

Rarely. Move commons to C tier once any rare or Epic outperforms them.